The 3 Best Pillowcases, Tested and Reviewed

Published on
Published on
Featured image for The 3 Best Pillowcases, Tested and Reviewed

Finding the right pillowcase is a highly personal endeavor. Just like a good set of sheets, pillowcases are the soft, cozy go-between you sleep on nightly—and the feel can affect your comfort overnight. After testing hundreds of sheet sets and their included pillowcases, we know what details make certain pillowcases stand above the rest, both in quality and in feel. We've spent hours and months sleeping on pillowcases from top-rated brands, putting them through tossing, turning, pillow flipping, and plenty of fluffing and reshaping. Our favorite pillowcases are those that are supremely soft to the touch. However, we've also found in our testing that the best pillowcases are those that are constructed with durability in mind.

Our Top Picks
California Design Den Cotton Pillowcases

California Design Den Cotton Pillowcases

For a more budget-friendly option, the California Design Den 400 Thread Count Cotton Pillowcases offer a comfortable sleeping surface that looks and feels way more expensive than their price tag. The envelope closure keeps the pillow covered and in place, making this a great pick for restless sleepers.
Feather & Stitch 100% Cotton Pillow Cases

Feather & Stitch 100% Cotton Pillow Cases

Nothing beats the reliably cozy feel of cotton bedding. The Feather & Stitch Cotton Percale Pillowcases are constructed with a 300-thread-count cotton percale weave for ultimate comfort. The fabric offers the crispness you’d expect of a percale weave with a medium weight. While certainly not as soft as the  L.L. Bean Premium Egyptian Cotton Percale Pillowcase, our best overall pick, we appreciated the substantial and sturdy construction of the Feather & Stitch pillowcase.
Brooklinen Mulberry Silk Pillowcase

Brooklinen Mulberry Silk Pillowcase

If you’re looking for an extra luxurious pillowcase, you may want to consider silk options. Silk’s texture makes it a great cooling fabric for hot sleepers who don’t love the static of a full silk sheet set but want their head and neck to be extra cool. We have not had the opportunity to test this silk pillowcase in the lab, but we are currently testing it at home and will update with more firsthand experience soon.
California Design Den Cotton Pillowcases

California Design Den Cotton Pillowcases

For a more budget-friendly option, the California Design Den 400 Thread Count Cotton Pillowcases offer a comfortable sleeping surface that looks and feels way more expensive than their price tag. The envelope closure keeps the pillow covered and in place, making this a great pick for restless sleepers.

Feather & Stitch 100% Cotton Pillow Cases

Feather & Stitch 100% Cotton Pillow Cases

Nothing beats the reliably cozy feel of cotton bedding. The Feather & Stitch Cotton Percale Pillowcases are constructed with a 300-thread-count cotton percale weave for ultimate comfort. The fabric offers the crispness you’d expect of a percale weave with a medium weight. While certainly not as soft as the  L.L. Bean Premium Egyptian Cotton Percale Pillowcase, our best overall pick, we appreciated the substantial and sturdy construction of the Feather & Stitch pillowcase.

Brooklinen Mulberry Silk Pillowcase

Brooklinen Mulberry Silk Pillowcase

If you’re looking for an extra luxurious pillowcase, you may want to consider silk options. Silk’s texture makes it a great cooling fabric for hot sleepers who don’t love the static of a full silk sheet set but want their head and neck to be extra cool. We have not had the opportunity to test this silk pillowcase in the lab, but we are currently testing it at home and will update with more firsthand experience soon.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the right pillowcase can truly elevate your sleep experience, offering the perfect balance of softness, durability, and quality. After extensive testing, the California Design Den Cotton Pillowcases, Feather & Stitch 100% Cotton Pillow Cases, and Brooklinen Mulberry Silk Pillowcase stood out as the top contenders for their exceptional craftsmanship and comfort. Whether you prefer the crisp feel of cotton or the luxurious touch of silk, these pillowcases are sure to complement your nightly routine and provide the restful sleep you deserve. Choose one that fits your style and needs—you can’t go wrong with any of these top picks!

Frequently Asked Questions

About author
Al

Alex Novis

Alexis Novis is a trusted expert in Amazon product comparisons and detailed reviews, dedicated to helping online shoppers make smart purchasing decisions. Specializing in providing expert insights, thorough feature breakdowns, and unbiased product recommendations, Alexis ensures every review is engaging, accurate, and easy to understand. With a focus on uncovering hidden gems and comparing top-rated products, Alexis creates content optimized for search engines and consumer trust. Whether you’re looking for the best deals or in-depth product analysis, Alexis Novis is your go-to resource for simplifying online shopping.

Smart Home, Technology & Garden Product Reviews, Comparisons & Buying Guides | Nexradar Smart Home, Technology & Garden Product Reviews, Comparisons & Buying Guides | Nexradar
Nexradar is a reader-supported platform, meaning we rely on your support to keep delivering honest and unbiased reviews. We never accept free products from manufacturers. By clicking on our links, you may help us earn a small commission, which directly funds our thorough testing and research.
This site uses cookies to improve your experience. You decide to Agree or not to our Privacy policy.